Dickinson Student Presentation: Sarah Mash
Sarah's Presentation: "A Moral Menace:" Understanding Incorrigible and Undesirable Students at the Carlisle Indian Industrial School Superintendent of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School (CIIS) Oscar Lipps identified troubled students as those who disrupted the school's functioning and reputation, including drunkards, students who were pregnant or had venereal disease, and those who were “generally undesirable” and insubordinate - a description consistent with runaway students. The language used by school officials to describe students who resisted assimilation, labeling them as "troubled," "incorrigible," and even a "moral menace," mirrored the terminology used for the mentally ill at the turn of the twentieth century. In this highly surveilled and militaristic environment characterized by isolation, surveillance, and a loss of freedom, students' feelings of hopelessness and despair were often minimized to homesickness and delinquency. Psychological concepts like "dissociated personality" resonate with the experience of Native students forced to shed their cultural identities and adopt a new American self, potentially leading to internal conflict and a breakdown in cognitive control. Race was a central and complicated factor at CIIS, influencing enrollment, treatment, and perceptions of students. Frequent inconsistencies in students' blood quantum records highlight the arbitrary nature of racial classification. The reconstruction of young alumnus Isaac’s life and suicide in 1918 seeks to further understand the complex experiences of Native American students within the institution of forced assimilation. As a student of both Sac and Fox and white heritage, Isaac’s story provides a powerful illustration of the damaging psychological and cultural impact of the federal assimilation and boarding school programs. His struggles with identity, acts of resistance, and suicide exemplify the consequences of forced assimilation and the need for a nuanced understanding of the diverse experiences of Native students caught between two worlds.
Two 30 Minute Sessions: "Colonialism and the Climate Crisis" & "Native Voices and Sovereignty"
** These sessions will be live-streamed.